SA Migration International

News Articles

Motsoaledi has made up his mind’: ZEP non-renewal will affect many lives, court hears

Source: The citizen, 20/09/2023

There are no prospects of success for Home Affairs` appeal application, according to the respondents.
The Helen Suzman Foundation has insisted that Home Affairs Minister Aaron Motsoaledi’s decision to terminate the Zimbabwean Exemption Permit (ZEP) programme without formal consultation was not in line with the law.
The full bench of the Gauteng High Court in Pretoria heard the Department of Home Affairs’ leave to appeal application on Monday.
Motsoaledi and Home Affairs director-general Tommy Makhode, who are the applicants in the litigation, are seeking an order to argue its case before the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA).
This follows the high court’s 28 June ruling which declared the termination of the ZEP unlawful and set it aside.
In their judgment, Judges Colleen Collis, Mandlenkosi Motha and Gcina Malindi ruled the matter go back to Motsoaledi for reconsideration due to the minister’s failure to conduct a proper public participation process.
The court also declared, pending the process, the ZEP would remain valid for the next 12 months.
‘Zero prospects of success’
Advocate Carol Steinberg, counsel for the Helen Suzman Foundation, argued during court proceedings that Motsoaledi failed in his duty to open formal discussions with permit holders before making a decision on the non-renewal of the ZEP in November 2021.
“It is common cause that this decision impacted on the lives of 178 000 people and their children and of course, all the South Africans whose lives are inextricably bound up with the 178 000 and in law there is a watertight obligation to hear what affected people have to say before a decision impacting on their lives is made.
“It is the first principle of natural justice. It’s common cause that the minister did not in fact hear from the affected people before making the decision {to terminate the ZEP] … he called for representations later,” she told the same full bench on Monday.
Steinberg said it did not matter whether the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act (PAJA) or the principle of legality was at play in the case.
“There is no court in South Africa that would ever say the minister would make a decision which profoundly impacts on the lives of many people without hearing from them first. This affects people’s whole lives, where they live, where their children go to school [and] how they earn a living,” the advocate said.
Earlier, Advocate William Mokhare had argued the court erred in its ruling by relying on the PAJA in determining that Motsoaledi did not afford ZEP holders a reasonable opportunity to make representations.
Watch proceedings below:
Steinberg, however, said there were no “realistic” prospect of success regardless of Home Affairs’ arguments.
“A mere possibility of success, an arguable case, or one that is not hopeless is not enough. In short, our argument is that there are actually zero prospects of success in this case,” she continued.
“The SCA, on repeated occasions, has frowned upon high courts granting leave to appeal where there is just no prospect of success and our submission is that there really can’t be.”
She said there was “no evidence” Motsoaledi applied his mind to this case and asked a punitive costs order against the minister.
“If there should be a genuine, non-frivolous challenge to the constitutionality of a law or state conduct, it is appropriate the state bear the costs if the challenge is good.
“So … there can never be a chilling affect on government in defending its conduct or a law because the state has a budget and needs to have a budget to defend its conduct or laws,” Steinberg said.
‘Minister has made up his mind’
Advocate David Simonsz, representing the Consortium for Refugees and Migrants in South Africa (Cormsa), supported Steinberg’s submissions, saying there were no compelling grounds to grant the appeal.
“Even on the principle of rationality, which is a common cause, there needs to be a fair opportunity to affect the mind of the decision-maker.
“The minister has been quoted on record as indicating that he has made up his mind on this issue,” the advocate told the court.
Simonsz argued the court’s judgment was not intended to allow the ZEP to continue indefinitely.
“The court sent this decision back to the minister,” he said, adding Home Affairs should reconsider the matter within the 12 months period afforded by the court in its initial ruling.
“The path is a clear one… what the minister should do is take the opportunity afforded to him by this court to follow a lawful process and make whatever decision he chooses to make once he takes into account the just and proper submissions and representations of those affected. That is the proper way forward.”
Judgment reserved
Meanwhile, Collis said the court’s judgment would be reserved and handed down after recess period.
“We are going to reserve our judgment on those two applications for leave to appeal, and then we will hand it down as soon as it is ready.
“Parties must bear in mind that the court is now on recess, so we accommodated the hearing of this application because you had set through the request during term already, but we will only hand down the judgment once the new term commences. We will advise the parties, and it will be uploaded onto case lines,” she said.

Search

Latest News

North Korean hackers have been exploiting the updating mechanism of the eScan antivirus to plant backdoors on big corporate networks and deliver cryptocurrency miners through GuptiMiner malware. Researchers describe GuptiMiner as `a highly sophisticated threat` that can perform DNS requests to the attacker`s DNS servers, extract payloads from images, sign its payloads, and perform DLL sideloading. Delivering GuptiMiner via eScan updates In a report released today, cybersecurity company Avast says that the threat actor behind GuptiMiner had an adversary-in-the-middle (AitM) position to hijack the normal virus definition update package and replace it with a malicious one named ‘updll62.dlz.’... Read more...

Airports Company South Africa (ACSA) this week revealed that Cape Town International Airport (CTIA) has achieved a ground-breaking milestone by processing more than 10 million passengers over a single financial year. This is the highest number of regional and international passengers processed since COVID-19... Read more...

DA MP says hours lost continue to result in persons being unable to collect their ID documents due to unmanageable queues The DA has been inundated with complaints that the Department of Home Affairs (DHA) systems are offline, resulting in long queues and delayed processing of documents. Through questions posed to the Minister, the DA can now reveal that the DHA has lost over 77 years’ worth of working hours due to system downtime and load-shedding from 2019 to date. Concerningly, this data only relates to hours lost for the application of smart IDs, meaning decades more of working hours could have been additionally lost in other spheres such as passport or visa applications.... Read more...

Home Affairs’ seemingly endless court battles set the department back more than R110-million between April 2023 and the end of February this year. This was revealed in a written parliamentary response by minister Aaron Motsoaledi. He said the department accumulated a litigation bill of R117 692 996.3, higher than the R72 637 944.51 spent the year before.... Read more...

Due to system downtime and load-shedding, the Department of Home Affairs (DHA) lost nearly 141,000 hours of Smart ID application and production time between the 2019/20 and 2022/23 financial years. Minister Aaron Motsoaledi revealed this figure in a recent response to questions raised in Parliament by Democratic Alliance MP Adrian Roos. Motsoaledi provided a breakdown of smart ID production and application hours lost to technical difficulties and load-shedding per province for each financial year from 2019/2020. These disruptions hit home Affairs offices in the Eastern Cape the hardest, with over 34,000 hours to rotational power cuts and system downtime. Mpumalanga offices lost the next-highest number of hours at 17... Read more...

In recent years, South Africa has seen a significant influx of immigrants from various African countries, as well as other parts of the world. This has raised important questions about the country`s immigration policies and their impact on job creation for both locals and immigrants. The South African immigration system, like many other countries, is a complex and ever-evolving process that aims to balance the country`s economic needs with its social and cultural interests. Let`s take a closer look at how this system intersects with job creation in South Africa. The South African government implemented the Immigration Act of 2002, which outlines the country`s immigration policies and procedures. Under this act, foreigners are required to obtain a visa or permit to enter, work, or study in South Africa. The type of visa or permit required depends on the intended purpose of the individual`s visit and their country of origin.... Read more...

The DA has been inundated with complaints that the Department of Home Affairs (DHA) systems are offline, resulting in long queues and delayed processing of documents. Through questions posed to the Minister, the DA can now reveal that the DHA has lost over 77 years’ worth of working hours due to system downtime and load-shedding from 2019 to date. Concerningly, this data only relates to hours lost for the application of smart IDs, meaning decades more of working hours could have been additionally lost in other spheres such as passport or visa applications. The lost hours are largely due to system downtime, surpassing load-shedding. In the 2022/2023 financial year, where we experienced extensive load-shedding, system downtime was the cause of 41 691 hours lost (17 years), whereas load-shedding caused around 9 322 hours lost (4 years) at DHA civic offices on the production of smart IDs.... Read more...

JOHANNESBURG - Minister of Home Affairs Aaron Motsoaledi said that while the White Paper on Citizenship, Immigration and Refugee Protection had been gazetted, there were amendments that needed to be made to the legislation before it could be passed into law. The White Paper is proposing an overhaul of the country`s migration laws, with the aim of tightening rules around allowing migrants into the country.... Read more...

Highly skilled professionals are leaving South Africa to move to other countries, while the local economy faces a skills shortage. Data from The Outlier revealed that there were just over 900,000 South Africans living abroad in 2020. This number has increased steadily over the past 20 years, from 500,000 in 2000, according to Stats SA’s Migration Profile Report for South Africa 2023. Of these 900,000 people, 7 out of 10 are living in either Europe or Oceania. In particular, Australia and New Zealand have seen a large growth in South African residents. In 2020, around 273,000 South Africans were living in those two countries, more than double the 106,000 who lived there in 2000. The UK remains still the top destination for South Africans who leave the country.... Read more...

Document proposes overhauling the Citizenship Act, the Refugees Act and the Immigration Act and a review of the international treaty on refugee protection Home affairs minister Aaron Motsoaledi says the cabinet has approved a white paper overhauling the country’s immigration laws after “robust engagements” that resulted in “wide support” of the document’s policy positions.... Read more...