SA Migration International

News Articles

Home affairs’ mean-spirited new immigration law should be scrapped

Source: Businessday, 28/02/2024

Lawyers for Human Rights say the white paper on citizenship violates SA’s own constitution and other international human rights laws
We all knew foreigners, most with degrees, who worked in SA for a decade or so helping build our new democracy. Who found local partners sometimes people of colour when that was still a novelty and threw the most banging and diverse dinner parties.
Then they were suddenly, inexplicably, forced to return to their countries of origin, leaving their families and spirits broken and our economy and society the poorer for their absence.
It is sobering to consider that 30 years into our once-celebrated democracy a minuscule 0.2% of the 62-million people living here have achieved citizenship by naturalisation.
Now, the department of home affairs is attempting to turn its white paper on immigration, citizenship and refugee protection into a mean-spirited new law regulating who belongs here and who supposedly doesn’t.
It is being taken to task for this by the likes of Lawyers for Human Rights (LHR), founded 45 years ago to try to mitigate the abuses of the apartheid regime, which argues that the white paper is so deeply problematic that it should be scrapped in its entirety.
Lawyers tend to prefer nitpicking over clauses in an attempt to clarify and improve them, so that’s a pretty drastic suggestion. But the problems start, LHR argues in its submission to the department, with an exceptionally limited time for public comment, aggravated by the document’s “lack of readability”.
“The white paper does not read coherently, nor does it provide credible assertions for the statements it makes or the statistics it provides. As a public policy document, this is unacceptable,” says LHR’s submission.
On the international stage, there is concern with the department’s stated intention to withdraw from the 1951 UN Convention and 1967 Protocol on the Status of Refugees (to which it acceded in 1996), as well as from the 1969 OAU convention on the same, “with a view to re-accede”, in LHR’s words, “with reservations and exceptions that seek to restrict the rights to health care, education and birth registration”.
At present pregnant migrant women are legally guaranteed pre- and postnatal care, and their children can be South African by birth. Though this is often thwarted in reality, it is now threatened entirely. The lawyers argue that withdrawal “poses significant risks for refugees and asylum seekers, including stateless refugees, and violates SA’s own constitution and other international human rights laws it is bound by”.
Though the hiatus period will create a climate of even greater vulnerability for migrants already threatened by poorly trained, corrupt or violent officials who tend to see all irregular or undocumented migrants as “illegal” withdrawal will not extricate SA from a complex interlocking set of international obligations to prevent torture, or to care for unaccompanied migrant children, for instance.
Only 0.2% of the 62-million people living in SA have achieved citizenship by naturalisation.
In particular, the principle of non-refoulement, of not returning asylum seekers to the country in which they were persecuted, remains an inflexible obligation. But LHR claims the white paper seeks to dodge this responsibility by claiming that if the seeker passed through a country deemed “safe” by the department en route to SA, then they did not come from a place of imminent danger.
However, the lawyers argue, there is no generally agreed “first safe country” principle in international law and even those countries that use it are obliged to protect all incoming refugees regardless.
“Broadly speaking,” LHR says, “the white paper proposes a number of measures that seek to narrow pathways to regularisation and access to documentation for asylum seekers and refugees. In addition, it seeks to withdraw the recognition of certain constitutional rights being afforded to migrants, including asylum seekers and refugees”.
It is worth stressing that many migrants are high-value contributors to society, like our former dinner-party hosts. In fact, a 2019 Helen Suzman Foundation breakdown of an Organisation for Economic Co-operation & Development-International Labour Organisation report showed that, on average, immigrants have a higher level of education than locals who don’t move between provinces seeking opportunities, and thus tend to to be self-employed and provide employment to citizens. Also, “high-skilled foreign-born workers raise GDP by 2.8% … and increase GDP per capita by 2.2%,” the study reads.
The foundation noted there was “no significant impact of the presence of immigrant workers on SA-born employment at the national level,” and that “the presence of ‘new’ immigrants, who have been in SA for less than 10 years, increases both the employment rate and the incomes of local workers.” This is in part because most migrants are un-unionised and do the dirty work South Africans are loathe to do; they seldom “take our jobs”, but rather push us into better-waged work.
Unfortunately, the critical question of SA’s human rights obligations to refugees and asylum seekers is being muddied by opportunistic and shallow scaremongering by political parties in the run-up to the national election, now scheduled for May 29. In the 2017 Human Sciences Research Council’s Social Attitudes Survey, 71% of the SA public identified the “threat” posed by immigrants as the main explanation for xenophobic violence.
A common error repeated in the media is the claim that SA has 15-million irregular migrants among our 62-million population, but Stats SA demographics chief Diego Iturralde says in fact there were only 3.96-million foreigners covering all legal statuses living in SA by 2022, up from the 2.2-million tallied by Census 2011.
Wits University-based fact-checking outfit Africa Check has stressed that the cited 15-million includes all people who do not have proper identity documents overwhelmingly these are South Africans, who, for reasons of poverty, remoteness or bureaucratic ineptness, do not possess a birth certificate or ID. But LHR warns that this number includes an extremely vulnerable grou more than 10,000 stateless people, among whom there is a large number of children.
Unfortunately, there is no proper process for dealing with statelessness, and SA deports 15,000-20,000 people every year, with the new Border Management Authority, launched in October 2023, stating that it prevented 44,000 people from entering the country in December 2023 alone.
Sitting in Modderbee Prison awaiting deportation as I write this is Pathy Zandu Tata, a charming 41-year-old Congolese draughtsman and illustrator. The authorities shouldn’t have detained him, as this has separated him from his beloved five-year-old daughter, which goes against a recent Constitutional Court ruling.
How did he earn a living here, you might ask? He worked as an electrician.

Search

Latest News

Due to system downtime and load-shedding, the Department of Home Affairs (DHA) lost nearly 141,000 hours of Smart ID application and production time between the 2019/20 and 2022/23 financial years. Minister Aaron Motsoaledi revealed this figure in a recent response to questions raised in Parliament by Democratic Alliance MP Adrian Roos. Motsoaledi provided a breakdown of smart ID production and application hours lost to technical difficulties and load-shedding per province for each financial year from 2019/2020. These disruptions hit home Affairs offices in the Eastern Cape the hardest, with over 34,000 hours to rotational power cuts and system downtime. Mpumalanga offices lost the next-highest number of hours at 17... Read more...

In recent years, South Africa has seen a significant influx of immigrants from various African countries, as well as other parts of the world. This has raised important questions about the country`s immigration policies and their impact on job creation for both locals and immigrants. The South African immigration system, like many other countries, is a complex and ever-evolving process that aims to balance the country`s economic needs with its social and cultural interests. Let`s take a closer look at how this system intersects with job creation in South Africa. The South African government implemented the Immigration Act of 2002, which outlines the country`s immigration policies and procedures. Under this act, foreigners are required to obtain a visa or permit to enter, work, or study in South Africa. The type of visa or permit required depends on the intended purpose of the individual`s visit and their country of origin.... Read more...

The DA has been inundated with complaints that the Department of Home Affairs (DHA) systems are offline, resulting in long queues and delayed processing of documents. Through questions posed to the Minister, the DA can now reveal that the DHA has lost over 77 years’ worth of working hours due to system downtime and load-shedding from 2019 to date. Concerningly, this data only relates to hours lost for the application of smart IDs, meaning decades more of working hours could have been additionally lost in other spheres such as passport or visa applications. The lost hours are largely due to system downtime, surpassing load-shedding. In the 2022/2023 financial year, where we experienced extensive load-shedding, system downtime was the cause of 41 691 hours lost (17 years), whereas load-shedding caused around 9 322 hours lost (4 years) at DHA civic offices on the production of smart IDs.... Read more...

JOHANNESBURG - Minister of Home Affairs Aaron Motsoaledi said that while the White Paper on Citizenship, Immigration and Refugee Protection had been gazetted, there were amendments that needed to be made to the legislation before it could be passed into law. The White Paper is proposing an overhaul of the country`s migration laws, with the aim of tightening rules around allowing migrants into the country.... Read more...

Highly skilled professionals are leaving South Africa to move to other countries, while the local economy faces a skills shortage. Data from The Outlier revealed that there were just over 900,000 South Africans living abroad in 2020. This number has increased steadily over the past 20 years, from 500,000 in 2000, according to Stats SA’s Migration Profile Report for South Africa 2023. Of these 900,000 people, 7 out of 10 are living in either Europe or Oceania. In particular, Australia and New Zealand have seen a large growth in South African residents. In 2020, around 273,000 South Africans were living in those two countries, more than double the 106,000 who lived there in 2000. The UK remains still the top destination for South Africans who leave the country.... Read more...

Document proposes overhauling the Citizenship Act, the Refugees Act and the Immigration Act and a review of the international treaty on refugee protection Home affairs minister Aaron Motsoaledi says the cabinet has approved a white paper overhauling the country’s immigration laws after “robust engagements” that resulted in “wide support” of the document’s policy positions.... Read more...

Minister Aaron Motsoaledi’s indifference to the plight of those affected by his decisions is appalling In the tumultuous seas of immigration law, where uncertainty looms and families are left adrift in bureaucratic limbo, the department of home affairs has emerged as a sinking ship. As a director of a firm of immigration attorneys I’ve witnessed first-hand the dire consequences of the department’s negligence and incompetence. Today, I raise my voice not just as an attorney but as a concerned citizen, urging for a radical overhaul to salvage what remains of our immigration system. We have tirelessly fought battles in the courtroom against home affairs’ disregard for agreed-upon time frames. Countless cases have landed on our desks, each one a testament to the systemic failures plaguing the department. We’ve seen cases where contempt applications were the only recourse, as the department brazenly ignored court orders.... Read more...

Home Affairs Minister Dr Aaron Motsoaledi has said the public has shown great support for the final White Paper on citizenship, immigration and refugee protection which appeared in the Government Gazette on Wednesday. Briefing the media, he addressed what he saw as a long-overdue need to replace an outdated Citizenship Act, as well as enact proposed changes to existing legislation.... Read more...

The Department of Home Affairs is going through a torrid time. As The South African reported earlier this year, naturalised South Africans are being refused smart ID cards. This is despite having the same constitutional rights as every other South African citizen. Now, Home Affairs minister Aaron Motsoaledi has decided to clarify the reasons behind lengthy delays for spousal visas.Business Tech reports that some spousal (and relatives) visas are taking up to two years to process. The minister of Home Affairs says this is because documentation and claims need to be verified. Replying to a parliamentary Q&A session, the minister says the issue is being addressed by the Home Affairs ‘Backlog Eradication Plan’.... Read more...

outh Africa seeks highly skilled individuals to live and work in SA. SA Migration Services will provide professional assistance to arrange your work visa for you if you qualify. Work Visas are regulated in terms of Section 19, Regulation 18 and items 18 (1), 19(2), 20, 21 and 22, of Schedule A.... Read more...