+27 (0)82 373 8415 info@sami.co.za Client Area login Assessment Form Visa Renewal Services


News Articles

Dual citizenship â€` SA’s diversity a check on claims to ‘who’s more South African’

Source: Daily Maverick, 08/11/2024




On Tuesday, the Constitutional Court heard arguments from the DA that sought to confirm a ruling by the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) that the government cannot remove someone’s citizenship simply because they are also a citizen of another country.The roots of this case go back more than a decade. The Home Affairs Ministry, currently headed by the DA’s Leon Schreiber, did not argue in the case, but simply said in court it would abide by its decision. This followed an earlier decision by his predecessor, the ANC’s Dr Aaron Motsoaledi. While he had first opposed the case, before the election this year, he had said publicly he would not oppose the ratification of the SCA’s judgment by the Constitutional Court.Legally, one of the questions at the heart of the case is whether the minister of Home Affairs has the power to make a decision that is so important to a person’s life.Under the law as it is currently, a South African who voluntarily becomes the citizen of another country while an adult and not through marriage (or birth, or what some countries’s citizenship laws refer to as “blood”) has to apply to the Minister of Home Affairs for permission to retain their South African citizenship.It appears that in some cases this has been granted, and in some cases not. What matters legally is that there are no clear criteria for these decisions. It appears it was simply the luck of the draw.‘Recipe for capricious decisions’This is why the SCA has already ruled against the current legislation. It was always going to be the case that one person should not be able to make such an important decision.As the court put it, this “is a recipe for capricious decision-making, without the specification of legitimate objects”.This means that the Constitutional Court is likely to order that people can be both citizens of South Africa and another country.This is in keeping with global trends, as it appears more countries now allow this. By at least one measure, 76% of countries have “acceptance” of expatriate dual citizenship. At the same time, it appears likely that more and more South Africans have dual citizenship. Many years ago it would have been expected that the DA would defend dual citizenship while the ANC might oppose it.But as our society has changed and opportunities have opened up, so more and more people born here have travelled. This probably affects the elite in our society more than other people. Leaders in political parties may well have family members who live in other countries and have dual citizenship. Or aspire to it.And they might well have some sympathy with those who have found their dual nationalities being used against them.People from as different backgrounds as former Prasa CEO Zolani Matthews and current deputy NPA head Anton du Plessis have had their security clearances denied simply because they were dual citizens. In both cases it appears they were the victims of mischief.As a result, the idea of restricting someone to just being a citizen of South Africa may feel simply, very Twentieth Century.In some ways it is surprising, considering all the discussions about identity that make up our politics, that we have never had national leaders claiming some people are “more South African” than others.Certainly, it is the kind of claim that would have huge political power, and could be used to win votes. And yet this hasn’t happened.This may be because of the historic insistence by the ANC that it governs for everyone. In other words, this is an offshoot of its policy of non-racialism, that “South Africa belongs to all who live in it”.DivisiveIt could also be a reflection of the fact that a real argument about who is “more South African” would be incredibly divisive.This means that those who campaign on identities based on ethnicity have the most to gain from such a debate, while those who campaign across ethnic identities have the most to lose.But this also means that the sheer diversity of our society provides a check on parties that want to make this an issue. It would be impossible to win a majority of votes by making such a claim because it would mean excluding appealing to broader groups of people.But this does not mean the issue will go away completely.There will always be those who argue you can only be “loyal” to one nation state, and that performing any act for another nation state could be disloyal.One example of this may be South African citizens who are also citizens of Israel.In December last year, the government issued a statement saying any South Africans who fought for the Israel Defense Forces could be violating South African law. Of course, this was primarily aimed at showing support for Palestinians who are under Israeli attack in Gaza. But it still shows some of the tensions that can arise through dual citizenship.This case, and the issues of citizenship it generates, may well have resonance with the recent increase in the expression of xenophobic sentiment.Issues around migration and people who were not born in South Africa, but are part of “All who live in it” have become fodder for some groups and some politicians.The decision by the former Cabinet and the former Home Affairs minister Dr Aaron Motsoaeldi to end the Zimbabwean Exemption Permit, and the legal action that followed, led to many discussions about foreign nationals living here.The current spate of deaths of young children after eating food bought from spaza shops has led to claims that foreign nationals are responsible. It would be foolish to think that groups that espouse xenophobia will not one day claim that dual citizens are not “truly South African”.That said, our society is changing in other ways too.Just as it is now accepted as wrong to judge someone based on their ethnicity, race or gender, so judging someone simply on where they were born may come to be seen as wrong.And many, many people in our society are aware that they are plugged into international networks. They may spend their working hours in meetings with people around the world.The recent publication of regulations for “digital nomads”, allowing people working in other countries to live here, is an official recognition of this trend.As a result, the concept of the nation state appears more and more like the fiction it is.While democracies change and evolve, so arguments about citizenship will change too. And this case might be an important step down the road to a much looser definition of what it means to be South African. DMThis article was updated on 7 November at 13H10 to more accurately reflect the correct interpretation of the Citizenship Act as it applies to how people become citizens of a second country.


Search

Search

Latest News

  •    South Africas Home Affairs and Employment and Labour departments have high-risk employment sectors in their sights and could soon crack down on illegal workers in the on-demand delivery space.This could pose a significant challenge for on-demand and fast food delivery services like Bolt, Checkers Sixty60, Pick n Pay asap!, and Uber Eats.While these companies vet and check driver identity documents as part of their signup processes, Home Affairs appears to have a significant fraud problem, and many of the asylum documents or work permits held by drivers may be fraudulent.Minister of Employment and Labour Minister Nomakhozana Meth, in response to recent parliamentary questions, said her department plans to target high-risk sectors.In partnership with law enforcement, the Departments of Home Affairs and Employment and Employment and Labour have been conducting raids at restaurants nationwide to identify and remove illegally employed foreigners.... Read more...
  •    Diaspora remittances by Kenyans living and working in South Africa have posted a recovery after years of subdued performance in the post-pandemic period largely on difficulties in getting work permits for skilled workers despite a visa-free deal between the two countries.Yes, the amount of money sent home by Kenyans in South Africa has increased despite difficulties with work permits: Remittances are up... Read more...
  •    The Department of Home Affairs (DHA) Counter Corruption and Security Services branch has busted various individuals, including the kingpin of a syndicate that helped businesses bring in illegal foreign nationals on forged documents.Thirty-four individuals have been dismissed from the department, of which 13 have been sentenced. Depending on their level of involvement, those convicted face jail time ranging from four to 26 years.This was revealed in the DHA Counter Corruption and Security Services branchs presentation to the Portfolio Committee of Home Affairs on Tuesday, 29 October 2024.The branch said it employed a multi-disciplinary approach to catch those involved in the syndicate after a whistle-blower informed it about foreign nationals getting South African passports through photo swap fraud.... Read more...
  •    Only an immigration officer may arrest a person deemed an illegal foreignerThe process of deporting illegal foreigners in South Africa is governed by the Immigration Act which empowers the home affairs department to arrest, detain and deport people who are not entitled to stay in the country. Home affairs minister Leon Schreiber, in a reply to a parliamentary question, said the department spent close to R53m between April and August to deport 19,750 illegal foreigners.The Scalabrini Centre of Cape Town, a nonprofit organisation which helps migrant communities and displaced people, details the process which must take place after someone has been found to be illegally in the country.... Read more...
  •    Germany and Somalia reached an agreement to deport undocumented Somali nationals from Germany.The German Chancellor, Olaf Scholz, said migrants without the right to stay in Germany would be repatriated quickly and effectively.At present, 65,000 Somalis live in Germany.The leaders of Germany and Somalia have agreed to step up the repatriation of undocumented Somalis in Germany.... Read more...
  •    On Tuesday, the Constitutional Court heard arguments from the DA that sought to confirm a ruling by the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) that the government cannot remove someone’s citizenship simply because they are also a citizen of another country.The roots of this case go back more than a decade. The Home Affairs Ministry, currently headed by the DA’s Leon Schreiber, did not argue in the case, but simply said in court it would abide by its decision. This followed an earlier decision by his predecessor, the ANC’s Dr Aaron Motsoaledi. While he had first opposed the case, before the election this year, he had said publicly he would not oppose the ratification of the SCA’s judgment by the Constitutional Court.Legally, one of the questions at the heart of the case is whether the minister of Home Affairs has the power to make a decision that is so important to a person’s life.... Read more...
  •    The tourism sector remains a cornerstone of the South African economy, driving economic growth and job creation. While various provinces are vying for the title of South Africas top tourist destination, Gauteng has consistently emerged as the popular choice for both domestic and international visitors.In a recent parliamentary response to the DAs Haseena Ismail, Tourism minister Patricia de Lille unpacked some of the key figures in the countrys critical sector since 2022.According to the minister, of the approximately ~5.7 million international tourists that visited South Africa between January and December of 2022, 2.3 million visited Gauteng, followed by Mpumalanga at 1.2 million and the Western Cape at 0.9 million.... Read more...
  •    Supporters of former US President and Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump celebrate as Fox News declares him the next President of the United States during an election night event at the West Palm Beach Convention Center in West Palm Beach, Florida, early on 6 November 2024Jim Watson/AFP Donald Trump will be sworn in as America`s 47th president in January, projections now show.With Georgia and North Carolina won for Trump, Fox News first called the election for him.Trump has promised big changes in America, and in its place in the world, with significant implications for South Africa.... Read more...
  •    The Minister and Director-General of Home Affairs will abide by the ConCourt`s decision.The Democratic Alliance (DA) says the South African citizenship for individuals who lost it after obtaining citizenship in another country should be reinstated.One such case involves Philip James Plaatjies, who lost his South African citizenship in 2007 after becoming a naturalised citizen of the United Kingdom (UK), following his marriage to a British woman three years prior.Unaware of the consequences, Plaatjies was affected by Section 6(1)(a) of the Citizenship Act, which states that South Africans automatically forfeit their citizenship if they voluntarily and formally acquire citizenship of another country.According to Section 6(2) of the Act, individuals must apply to the Minister of Home Affairs to retain their South African citizenship before obtaining foreign citizenship.DA challenges Citizenship ActPlaatjies’ pursuit of dual citizenship led the DA to challenge the constitutionality of Section 6(1)(a) of the Citizenship Act.... Read more...
  •    The reinstatement of the plan to offer early retirement to senior civil servants as part of a broader strategy to reduce the nations high public sector wage bill has been met with mixed reactions with critics arguing that it will result in a brain drain in the countrys civil service.The medium-term budget policy statement (MTBPS) tabled by finance minister Enoch Godongwana on 30 October noted that the government was proposing to reactivate early retirement without penalties in 2025/26 and 2026/27 in a bid to further contain public service wage costs amid a deteriorating fiscus.To support this initiative, an additional R11 billion will be allocated over the next two fiscal years. Details will be set out in the 2025 Budget, stated the budget documents.The MTBPS highlighted that the public sector wage bill represents the governments most substantial financial challenge.... Read more...
South Africa Immigration Company